CAUSAL UNCERTAINTY: ALTERNATIVE CAUSATION IN TORT LAW

Mihajlo Cvetković

DOI Number
https://doi.org/10.22190/TEME191115007C
First page
033
Last page
047

Abstract


The causal link between the tortfeasor’s unlawful act and the resulting damage is an essential element of tort liability. There are situations in tort law practice where singular damage has more than one potential cause, so it is important to determine which one is legally relevant. In those situations, it is hard for the claimant to identify the tortfeasor. Moreover, proving the causal link is difficult or almost impossible. On the contrary, the tortfeasor can successfully object that the damage cannot be attributed to him/her. European courts and doctrine have developed theories about alternative causation firstly by addressing asbestos litigation. This paper presents solutions from English, Belgian, French, German and Dutch tort law. Although they all strive for the same goal - fair compensation, the diversity of methods and outcomes is surprising. The end of the paper is devoted to the Principles of European Tort Law (PETL), where optimal suggestions on how to overcome causal uncertainty are presented.


Keywords

tort, asbestos, cause, uncertainty, burden of proof

Full Text:

PDF

References


Barker v Corus (UK) plc (2006) UKHL 20

BGB: Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch BGBl. I S. 42, 2909; (2003) I S. 738. 31. Januar BGBl. I S. 54 (2019)

Busnelli, F. D., Comandé, G., Cousy, H., Dobbs, D. B., Dufwa, B. W., Faure, M. G., Gilead, I., ... Widmer, P. (2005). Principles of European Tort Law: Text and Commentary. Vienna: Springer Vienna.

Coggiola, N. (2013). Causation in Mesothelioma Cases in the Italian Courts. European Review of Private Law, 21(1), 331-339.

Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd (2002) UKHL 22

G’Sell, F. (2017). Alternative Causation under French Law. European Review of Private Law, 25(6), 1109-1115.

NBW: Nieuwe Burgerlijk Wetboek. Nederland. 1 januari (1992)

Nefalit/ Karamus, Hoge Raad 31 maart 2006 (ECLI:NL:HR:2006:AU6092)

Samii, S. M., & Keirse, A. (2013). Taxonomy of Asbestos Litigation in the Netherlands: Duelling with Causal Uncertainty. European Review of Private Law, 21(1), 341-370.

Sienkiewicz v Greif (2011) UKSC 10

Vandenbussche, W. (2017). Alternative causation in asbestos cases under Belgian law. European Review of Private Law, 25(6), 1141-1151.

Wagner, G. (2013). Asbestos-Related Diseases in German Law. European Review of Private Law, 21(1), 319-329.

Zimmermann, R., Winiger, B., Koziol, H., & Koch, B. A. (2007). Digest of European Tort Law, Bd. I: Essential Cases on Natural Causation. Springer Wien New York. 2007. ISBN 978-3-211-36957-9




DOI: https://doi.org/10.22190/TEME191115007C

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Print ISSN: 0353-7919
Online ISSN: 1820-7804